On this page: Executive SummaryKey FindingsRelated Hearings and Research
Executive Summary
China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea are forging closer strategic, military, and economic ties that increase their ability—individually and collectively—to challenge the interests of the United States and its allies and partners around the world. These states share common objectives in undermining U.S. global leadership and elements of the international system that promote democracy and human rights, while seeking to reshape them to endorse autocratic rule and the use of coercion and military force to advance national interests. Although the relationships among China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea may not constitute an alliance as traditionally conceived, the partnerships allow the countries to consider the use of force, undertake provocative actions, and otherwise act in ways they could not sustain on their own. This cooperation has intensified since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022, as China, Iran, and North Korea have provided Russia with political, economic, and military support to sustain its war of aggression, allowing it to circumvent U.S. and international sanctions and diplomatic pressure. As the alignment is based more on shared interests and expediency than trust and loyalty, each country may decline to assist meaningfully when counterproductive to their larger objectives, as China and Russia did after the United States struck nuclear facilities in Iran in June.
As the most powerful and systemically integrated of these countries, China has been the “decisive enabler” of this group and its destabilizing activities. By cooperating with—and legitimizing— these heavily sanctioned countries, Beijing has developed significant leverage over them, effectively casting them as junior partners in the relationship. While this dynamic has generated some underlying friction, the advantages gained from their collective power have outweighed the disadvantages. To respond to this increasing alignment among China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea, the United States must work in concert with allies and partners to deter destabilizing activities and prepare to respond to multiple potential regional flashpoints. Unfortunately, the necessity to confront this challenge has come at a time when growing divisions within many democratic societies have undermined their willingness and ability to act in a concerted fashion to resist these efforts.
Key Findings
- China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea are forging closer strategic, military, and economic ties that increase their ability—individually and collectively—to challenge the strategic interests of the United States and its allies. This cooperation is rooted in a shared desire to undermine U.S. global leadership and reshape elements of the rules-based international order, including concepts of sovereign equality, peaceful resolution of conflict, and respect for human rights. Instead, the countries seek an order that favors autocratic governance and their capacity to extend their regional spheres of influence.
- While China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea individually pose a significant threat to U.S. interests, their growing cooperation collectively magnifies the challenge. Each is emboldened to undertake actions it could not sustain on its own, and their cooperative efforts make it far more difficult to secure U.S. national security, economic prosperity, and peace and stability around the world.
- Cooperation among the “axis” countries has deepened since Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, as Russia has drawn on China, Iran, and North Korea to support its war efforts and to help it overcome the subsequent international condemnation and sanctions. For example, China-Russia bilateral trade has increased 66.7 percent since 2021. Each axis country has also benefited in different ways from its support to Moscow.
- China has played the central diplomatic, economic, and financial role in this informal alignment. These relationships have become increasingly asymmetric, with China effectively casting the others as junior partners. While this dynamic has generated some underlying friction, such tensions have largely been mitigated by shared interests and mutual benefits.
- As the alignment is based more on shared interests and expediency than trust and binding obligation, each country has freedom of action and the ability to decline to participate in a conflict. This flexibility was evident in the failure of China and Russia to provide support to Iran after the United States struck its nuclear facilities in June.
- China’s preference for flexible partnerships over formal alliances reflects its opportunistic approach to diplomacy, in which it seeks to take advantage of a relationship that serves its interests while avoiding entanglements that do not benefit it. Beijing seeks to have it both ways—cooperating closely with these partners that defy international norms and institutions while simultaneously trying to promote an image as a responsible stakeholder to the broader international community that values those norms and institutions.
- China’s deepening cooperation with Russia, Iran, and North Korea raises significant concerns for Indo-Pacific security. Their coordination increases the risk of opportunistic aggression, a situation in which one regional conflict creates an opening for another actor to take advantage of the United States’ diverted attention and resources to launch operations elsewhere. In a Taiwan contingency, such dynamics could force the United States to face tough choices on escalation and resource allocation. The collaboration among these powers substantially increases the risk of regional conflicts transforming into broader global crises.
- China is the major trade and investment partner for these countries, helping them mitigate the adverse effects of U.S. and multilateral sanctions. Chinese entities have been instrumental in facilitating circumvention of export controls. China’s opaque financial system has been vital in money laundering and sanctions evasion by Russian, Iranian, and North Korean agents. Together, China’s policies have provided a lifeline that has allowed these countries access to the resources, technologies, and dual-use equipment needed to stay in power and continue destabilizing activities.
- The sum of China’s sanctions and export control evasion activities is greater than the individual components. China’s role as a hub for a diverse array of countries’ sanctions evasion activities effectively allows for pooling of resources and economies of scale for companies and service providers that facilitate sanctions evasion. The network effect of Chinese and non-Chinese actors creates shared learning opportunities about evasion tactics, presenting new challenges for sanctions strategy and enforcement.