On this page: Executive SummaryKey Findings
Executive Summary
Beijing has dissolved the final vestiges of Hong Kong’s political freedom, eliminating the last opposition party and expanding on the draconian Article 23 Ordinance to tighten its oversight of Hong Kong’s legal system under an expansive definition of “national security.” Civil society and free speech have followed similar fates, as authorities have largely succeeded in intimidating Hong Kong’s citizens to discourage them from engaging in open opposition. The government has increased vigilance against so-called “soft resistance” at home while offering bounties on dissidents abroad. Nonetheless, attempts to assuage foreign businesses operating in Hong Kong appear initially successful, even as it is clear Beijing sees Hong Kong primarily as an extension of the Mainland’s development objectives. Although Hong Kong officials maintain a pretense of independence in order to court international investment, the expansion of “national security” into all domains and pressure on private firms to operate in line with Beijing’s political objectives make Hong Kong’s system increasingly indistinguishable from the Mainland.
Key Findings
- As the Hong Kong government marked the fifth anniversary of the National Security Law, its ongoing crackdown has eliminated a once vibrant civil society and created an atmosphere of repression comparable to mainland China. The Hong Kong government continues to grant the Mainland authority and oversight of the city, passing legislation to award Beijing additional powers to intervene in local law enforcement via the Office for Safeguarding National Security (OSNS).
- Hong Kong security forces have expanded a campaign of transnational repression against leaders of the democracy movement who fled abroad, placing bounties on an additional 15 activists—including two Canadian citizens—canceling passports, and blocking access to their pensions. Authorities have also escalated harassment of activists’ family members still in Hong Kong.
- After an exodus of foreign firms following China’s imposition of the National Security Law in 2020, a concerted charm offensive to retain international business and rehabilitate Hong Kong’s pro-commerce image appears to be bearing fruit. Many foreign firms remain in Hong Kong due to its proximity to mainland China.
- Hong Kong has emerged as an export controls and sanctions evasion hub, facilitating international transactions with and flows of restricted goods and advanced technology to Russia, Iran, and North Korea.
- Beijing’s intervention to block CK Hutchison from selling its port investments, including in the Panama Canal, makes clear that Hong Kong firms are now subject to Chinese Communist Party (CCP) directives and that the Party will interfere in commercial transactions to advance its geostrategic objectives. For foreign firms and financial institutions operating in Hong Kong, this interference should be seen as an alarming precedent. Beijing could invoke the National Security Law to intervene in Hong Kong’s civil proceedings, and the expanding reach of national security legislation could be used to interfere with transactions even with no mainland China or Hong Kong nexus.