On this page: Executive SummaryKey FindingsRelated Hearings and Research
Executive Summary
China’s economic model continues to generate a major imbalance between weak domestic demand and excess supply of manufactured goods. China uses its excess capacity to manufacture goods like steel and automobiles at a scale it cannot consume on its own, leading to extreme price wars between producers. Rather than attempt to rebalance its economy, China is exporting its economic distortions in the form of low-priced goods, thereby threatening the world with a second “Shock.” This China Shock 2.0 is already upending manufacturing sectors in both developing and developed countries, up and down the value chain, as China’s flood of exports is no longer limited to low-value-added goods like furniture and clothing. While these industries are more at risk than before, China has also begun to produce higher-value-added goods at scale, the result of years of technology theft, government subsidies, and aggressive industrial policies.
The glut of Chinese exports is deepening global market dependence on China and exacerbating supply chain vulnerabilities. Regions like Southeast Asia that once benefited from global trade integration are now at risk of deindustrialization as their exports are undercut by Chinese goods. Germany, South Korea, and Japan are also at risk as their basket of exports increasingly resembles China’s. Beyond merely carving out a larger share of global profits for Chinese corporations, China’s market dominance is translating into control over chokepoints in key global supply chains for goods like pharmaceuticals and electronics. China’s investment in manufacturing facilities abroad undercuts efforts by the United States and its allies and partners to diversify production to other emerging markets.
Responses to this new Shock have been fragmented, relying on outdated tools that no longer match the reality of today’s global trading system. Additionally, incentives to push back on these export practices are not always aligned with the desire to continue selling commodities to China or benefiting from Chinese outbound foreign direct investment (FDI). At risk are not just today’s factories and jobs in manufacturing: as China floods global markets with its goods, it will gain a more dominant share of key markets, gutting foreign competitors and propelling them into a downward spiral of deindustrialization (the focus of this chapter). This in turn will lead to greater control over critical supply chain chokepoints (the focus of the next chapter). Beijing has already shown its willingness to weaponize its control of the critical minerals sector; a new China Shock will further strengthen China’s leverage over supply chains and ability to employ economic coercion to advance its interests.
Key Findings
- The world is facing the threat of a China Shock 2.0, whereby overproduction in key industries across China’s highly subsidized manufacturing sector floods outward, causing major harm to industries in other countries. China Shock 2.0 is a manifestation of General Secretary of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) Xi Jinping’s economic plan—massive state subsidies and other distortions to boost production, reliance on foreign markets to absorb the excess supply, and minimal attention to addressing continued, structurally weak domestic demand.
- China’s export of excess production is undercutting global competitors and winning market share across the value chain, from commodities to intermediate inputs to finished goods. China’s economic model increasingly limits other emerging market countries to the lowest-value-added stages of manufacturing.
- Emerging markets have traditionally been welcoming to Chinese FDI in manufacturing, viewing it as an opportunity to facilitate labor upskilling and the development of local industry. However, Chinese FDI poses potential problems for host countries as well. Chinese officials are increasingly reluctant to allow domestic firms to transfer technology abroad, lessening benefits to host countries. In addition, Chinese FDI may deepen reliance on Chinese inputs and open the host country to concerns that it serves as a base for Chinese transshipment or tariff evasion.
- In emerging markets, China’s surging exports have already led to job losses and factory closures. Emerging market countries have begun to wake up to the threat, employing various tools to push back against China’s unfair trade practices and preserve local industry and jobs, with varying degrees of success. International trade agreements have proven less durable protection; in many cases they merely constrain the policy responses of China’s trading partners, facilitating the harms from China Shock 2.0, even though China’s economic model is inconsistent with the foundational assumptions of those trade agreements.
- China’s surging exports of higher-end goods are taking market share from producers in other countries, particularly those in developed countries, including the United States. While emerging markets are imperiled by other aspects of China Shock 2.0, they have little incentive to implement barriers to Chinese exports in those industries that do not compete with local manufacturing. Over time, the long-term harm to U.S. and other non-Chinese producers may be significant. Revenue from foreign markets has helped sustain U.S. economic strength and technological leadership by providing opportunities to scale. Losing this revenue will make it harder to invest in next generation technology.